Trial on Scab

by on July 21, 2015
in Vegetable Growing

Further to my earlier article on Common Scab and as a reply to Simon Smith, I did a trial last Spring on two Kestrel potatoes that had scab, one had far too much scab on for exhibition and the other was even worse and just fit for pigs!

Kestrel Potato with such severe Scab that pigs would have turned their noses on it!!

Kestrel Potato with such severe Scab that pigs would have turned their noses on it!!

Kestrel Potato with Scab, and would not have shown on in this condition

Kestrel Potato with Scab, and would not have shown on in this condition

I planted both in my own potato mixture and in the usual poly bags with nothing else added. They were positioned as the first two bags in the rows so that I could really monitor how dry the bags were. They were kept evenly moist throughout and the resulting crop were lovely and clean.

Result from both bags mixed together with very clean skins.

Result from both bags mixed together with very clean skins.

the crop from one bag (smaller than normal)

the crop from one bag (smaller than normal)

So it must prove that the common scab doesn’t pass on from seed potatoes to the following crop. One bag had  a smaller quantity than the other but I could have had a decent set for a good local show. Other factors of course can affect the scab such as a high PH in either your soil or compost, or obviously leaving them dry at the potato development or initiation stage.

Comments

4 Responses to “Trial on Scab”
  1. Simon Smith says:

    Cheers Medwyn. Perhaps people will believe me now, and more importantly stop giving their suppliers such a hard time! At the end of the day, if you get scab on your spuds it’s your own failt, no-one else’s!

  2. Simon Smith says:

    And that’s fault not failt! Buttons on phone keyboards these days are way too small! A bit like my stumps!

  3. Marcus says:

    Most of my Winston seed this year had scab on them. I have now emptied the bags and not one spud had scab on it 🙂

  4. Simon Smith says:

    I think you’d be hard pushed to find a seed spud that HASN’T got a scab lesion on it somewhere.

Share Your Thoughts