National Kelsae Onion Festival
23rd Dec 1999
· Sowing Exhibition Long Carrots
· Staging Vegetables on the Show...
· Long Carrots and Leeks
· F1 Hybrid Exhibition Onions
· The Onion Beds
· Vegetables for Home and...
· Up-date on the Shallots +...
· Artificial Lighting and...
· High Quality Potatoes
· "Show Perfection" Peas
· Exhibition Celery, Onions and...
· Outstanding Vegetables +...
· ABC of Vegetables - Part 4
· Short Carrots - Germination,...
· Growing Quality Exhibition...
Continuation of last week's article.
The National Kelsae Onion Festival was organised by Sinclair McGill Ltd in 1975, they were seed merchants who had the sole rights to the Kelsae onion and this competition was undoubtedly the dream of Robin Hogg. Robin was at the time part of the management team and was responsible for the selection of onions to make sure that the Kelsae remained the one to beat on the show scene.
Another interesting point, and probably the main reason for Robin's interest, is the fact that his father, T Hogg improved a sport from the Kelsae onion during the 1950's and as it was distinctly different to the Kelsae it was called the ‘Border' onion. During the 50s and 60s there was great rivalry and competition between the two types of onion but in the end the Kelsae onion dominated to the extent that the Border onion ceased to be grown. Even though the ‘Border' at that time could achieve a circumference of 22inches (which was unbelievably large) it's downfall undoubtedly was it's rather flat shape.
The man who really moved things forward though was Mel Ednie, even today, five years on, he is still the world record holder for the heaviest onion with a stupendous specimen weighing 15lb 15.5 ounces and measuring over 33 inches in circumference. Interestingly this record was broken at the home of the Kelsae onion at Kelso in Scotland on a Saturday in September. Equally interesting is the fact that Mel had broken the previous World record on the Friday before with an onion weighing 15lbs 9 ounces, so he broke the World Record twice in two days! This record will certainly last for many years to come, since Mel broke it, no one has come within a few pounds to it.
Mel was a keen Chrysanthemum grower in the days before he attempted to grow onions and the strange thing is that a number of the top growers such as Ivor Mace Vin Throup and Mel have all grown Chrysanthemums to the highest standards. During the 1980 - 81 season Mel decided to have ago at growing the large onions and was given some onion plants from Bob Rodger with which he did remarkably well. In those early days there's no doubt that the influence of the two great growers Bob and Bill Rodger helped Mel to get on to the right track. Mel however is very much a thinking gardener himself and over the latter years has certainly worked things out himself.
When I recently spoke to Mel I asked him if he would ever have a go at breaking his own record, his reply was that he might well do so once he retires from his regular employment as a builder. I just hope that I shall be around to see that day.
Below is a list of the winners of all the Kelsae Heaviest Onion competition from the first show in 1975 to the present day where they are now held at the Harrogate Show Ground and run by the North of England Horticultural Society. This years heaviest onion competition was the 25th to be staged and during that period 8 World records were established.
|
Date |
Venue |
Name of Winner |
Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
|
1975 |
Sinclair McGill Ltd Boston |
A. C breed St Boswells Roxburghshire |
4lb 15.75 ozs |
|
1976 |
Barton Grange Garden Centre Garstang Preston |
J Wheildon Brimstage Wirral |
5lb 10ozs |
|
1977 |
Mayfield Garden Centre Kelso |
R Rodger Crail Fife |
5lb 13.5ozs |
|
1978 |
Dickens Garden Centre Stockton on Tees |
B H Charles Oswestry Shropshire |
4lb 4.5 ozs |
|
1979 |
Grosvenor Garden Centre Chester |
G White York |
5lb 5.5ozs |
|
1980 |
Mayfield Garden Centre Kelso |
R Rodger Crail Fife |
6lb 0.5ozs |
|
1981 |
Harlow Car Gardens Harrogate |
R Rodger Crail Fife |
6lb 7ozs (*see below) |
|
1982 |
Northern Club Ashington Northumberland |
J McKenzie Maryport Cumbria |
6lb 12ozs |
|
1983 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
J McKenzie Maryport Cumbria |
7lb 3.5ozs |
|
1984 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
S. Shakeshaft Raby Wirral |
7lb 7.00ozs * * |
|
1985 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
W Rodger Crail Fife |
6lb 14.5ozs World Record |
|
1986 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
Vin Throup Silsden Yorkshire |
7lb 4.5ozs |
|
1987 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
Ivor Mace Ynys Wen Rhondda Valley |
8lb 13ozs * * |
|
1988 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
Keith Foster Richmond North Yorkshire |
9lb 2.0ozs * * |
|
1989 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
Vin Throup Silsden Yorkshire |
9lb 11ozs * * |
|
1990 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
Vin Throup Silsden Yorkshire |
10lb 14ozs * * |
|
1991 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
Peter Glasebrook Halam Newark |
10lb 9ozs |
|
1992 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
Robert Holland Cumnock Ayrshire |
11lb 2.0ozs * * |
|
1993 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
Robert Holland Cumnock Ayrshire |
11lb 1.75ozs |
|
1994 |
Great Autumn Show Exhibition Ctr.Harrogate |
Mel Ednie Anstruther Fife |
12lb 4.0ozs * * |
|
1995 |
Great Autumn Show Yorks Show Grd Harrogate |
Mel Ednie Anstruther Fife |
15lb 15.5ozs** |
|
1996 |
Great Autumn Show Yorks Show Grd Harrogate |
Mel Ednie Anstruther Fife |
13lb 3.0ozs |
|
1997 |
Great Autumn Show Yorks Show Grd Harrogate |
Mel Ednie Anstruther Fife |
13lb 0.0ozs |
|
1998 |
Great Autumn Show Yorks Show Grd Harrogate |
Donald Kaye Sowood Halifax Yorkshire |
13lb 8.8ozs |
|
1999 |
Great Autumn Show Yorks Show Grd Harrogate |
E Walker Barnsley South Yorkshire |
11lb 7.62ozs |
* Later that year at the Northern Club Show Ashington, a World Record was achieved by S Hill of Galashiels with a 7lb 6oz onion after trimming the foliage.
* * New World Record set.